We advise general liability and product liability insurers of manufacturers, businesses, condominiums and public bodies, in Italy and abroad. At the core of our work are coverage disputes on policy wording: operation of cover, limitation and exclusion clauses, third-party status, rules of contractual interpretation and allocation of the burden of proof between insured and insurer.
Recurring issues
- Arts. 1362 ff., 1370 and 1341 Civil Code
- Burden of proving the policy terms
- Third-party status of relatives, cohabitants and contractors
- Damage to the works and contractual liability towards the principal
- Escape of water
- Average clause
- Notion of producer and component
- Different risk
- Installation and maintenance exclusions
- Subrogation
- Foreign claims, forum-selection clauses, punitive damages and bad faith
Selected decided cases
Reported anonymously and in full respect of confidentiality.
- High Court of Hong Kong, 2021 and 2023 – product liability for Italian-made machinery: litigation handled through local counsel and settled by court-sealed consent order; the subsequent subrogation action closed on limitation and standing grounds under common law.
- Superior Court of Los Angeles – product liability: the Californian court declined jurisdiction over the claim against the insurer on the basis of the contractual forum clause.
- Court of Trani, 2025 – general liability cover held inoperative for the contractor’s contractual liability towards the principal and for damage to the works.
- Court of Rome, 2026 – the insured’s indemnity claim for an accident caused to her cohabiting partner was dismissed.
From our Osservatorio (in Italian)
- Responsabilità di un terzo anche se non parte del giudizio
- La copertura assicurativa RC PRODOTTI è esclusa ogni qualvolta si è dinnanzi ad un vizio integrante un mero difetto di qualità e non già un effetto pregiudizievole.
Other areas
- Medical and healthcare liability – Facilities, physicians and their insurers, from pre-trial assessment to the Supreme Court.
- Employers’ liability – workplace accidents – Differential damage, INAIL recovery, policy limits and multiple duty-holders.
- Personal accident – Permanent disability, medical panels, non-disclosure and limitation.
- Health and sickness – Disability from illness, annuities, pre-contractual disclosure.
- Life insurance – Term life, beneficiaries, linked policies, intermediaries.
- Motor liability and recovery actions – Major claims, Guarantee Fund, contractual recourse and contribution.
- Anti-fraud – Rapid advice, evidence, criminal action and civil remedies.
- Risk assessment and foreign claims – Risk opinions, technical reserving, supervision of major foreign claims.
To discuss a claim or a portfolio: contact us.
